Hiatus

0 comments

Hi! Many thanks to readers, especially returning readers for checking back. Due to schoolwork (Java programming), research work (running simulations) and part-time work (alumni giving call center), I can't find time to post on HoViVo. I'm taking a break, but I'll definitely post some thoughts after DiaS'pura.

Re-examining Nantah's History (using Google Books)

0 comments

Re-examining Nantah's History
Using Google BookSearch

Political autobiographers have vested interests. Just today, the New York Times reported that Hillary Clinton contradicted events described in her autobiography.

According to Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew's autobiography From Third World to First (Google BookSearch), Nantah suffered negative externalities from being a Chinese-medium school. He recalls that Nantah had to lower "requirements for both admission and pass standards for graduation, further diminishing its academic reputation and market value for its graduates." He characterized himself as a passionate savior of Nantah, with a practical outlook and the support of MPs who were Nantah alumni. Against the sentiment of "most of [his] cabinet colleagues," MM Lee decided to "stir up a hornet's nest"to arrest the problem of Nantah graduates' lack of fluency in English at its infancy. In summary, he led the government to save Nantah from its unavoidable demise against the irrationality of Nantah's emotional alumni.

Wang Gungwu, currently Director of the East Asian Institute at the National University of Singapore, offered a different take when interviewed for the book Diasporic Chinese Ventures: The Life and Work of Wang Gungwu (Google BookSearch). He said, "Nantah...suffered active discrimination...neither [Malaysia/Singapore] government was prepared to recognize them." That was before Singapore gained independence from Malaysia. Later in the interview, he attributed the decline of Nantah to Singapore no longer admitting Malaysian students, when at Nantah "three out of five students were graduates of Malaysian middle schools, some of which were stronger than their counterparts in Singapore."

Wang's account does not directly negate Lee's, but highlights that Nantah's situation then was more complex than just of its medium of instruction. Unfortunately, almost all secondary official Singapore accounts have followed Lee's story without mention of Wang's portions. (for example: the Library Board's and news reports on Channel News Asia etc)

I have great respect for MM Lee - he is a shrewd politician who has led Singapore decisively for decades. Yet the history of many cannot be written by a single hand, and we as Singaporeans need to understand our history in holistic ways.

The blind anger against MM Lee for subsuming Nantah under NUS has faded, the Nantah alumni probably have college-age kids by now. I believe MM Lee's good name will stand to gain further with more re-examining of our history. Right now his name is sullied (mostly abroad) by the extremist-anti-PAP camp who has the argument that Singaporeans are ignorant of "the truth." These anti-PAPers go around fashioning themselves as martyrs liberating us ignorant masses. It is time to remove their weapon of accusation, to open up and re-examine the history books, so they can no longer argue that PAP is popular because of its singular grip on history. As the Nantah story tells us, history is more complex than that.

---
This is the first in a series examining the ideas of "Singapore" and "Diaspora," in anticipation of DiaS'pura at Penn. Prof. Chan Heng Chee, Singapore's Ambassador to the US, Prof. Janice R. Bellace, Founding President of Singapore Management University, and Francis Seow, will speak at the event. Although the website of DiaS'pura lists Francis Seow as a Fellow at both Harvard and Yale, I failed to find information from either Harvard's or Yale's website that indicates he is still currently of those positions.

There is no official partnership between HoViVo and DiaS'pura, I'm just writing with an interest as a Penn alumnus and Singaporean.

Obscure Back Roads

1 comments

[Fiction - Draft] Part 4, originally written May 2006
What happened was that for a few months after Tina came back from four years of Manhattan, she couldn't date. She remembers stifling her shivers whenever she met men who spoke with such strong Singlish accents. And one of them was promising enough, until he confessed he would rather be watching Mr and Mrs Smith than "slow" Annie Hall. Then somehow Damien came into her life. She was idling at Clarke Quay's tcc, pondering over a random tourist's comment that "everything is too new here" when he intruded, not giving her time to compose herself:

'And I don't suppose you're the ST journalist?"

He'd said it in such a casual manner that his accent had failed to register.

Related posts:
Part 1 of story - Dinner Music for People who aren't Very Hungry
Part 2 of story - The Sound of Silence
Part 3 of story - New Amsterdam

P65 MPs: Style over Substance?

6 comments

Singapore Post-1965 Politicians: Style over Substance?
Dancing their ways to our hearts, snaking their ways to our minds

Style
Barack Obama is a lesson in style - people trust and are charmed by him. He appears on shows like Conan, and young voters eagerly reach back to him. In the same fashion, our P65 MPs are signaling their desire to connect to us. Us - the group of post-65ers who will make up the majority of voters in the next election. But we just laugh at them. And at best the journalist writing for the Associated Press about P65 Chingay was restraining his smirk.

Are we observers hypocrites? Weren't we the ones who wanted PAP to loosen up from their paternalistic ways? I have a parallel first hand experience - I was a student councilor in JC. Mass dances are huge at my JC, and being responsible for devising new dances and passing on traditional ones, we councilors spent time practicing, performing and leading dances. Some students weren't impressed, they thought we cared too much for dancing - and we weren't even good at it. I enjoyed dancing but realized I was no dancer. But I danced on. Maybe I was pushed by more senior members of the establishment because they thought it was crucial in our service to students. Definitely I felt a passion to serve my fellow students. Yet style is a two-way street - not just about exhibiting, but about listening to feedback and reacting...stylishly.

If you pardon my example, aren't dances usually as mating rituals? So what are the p65 MPs using it as a vehicle for - substance?

Substance
To give them some credit
True to PAP, our P65 MPs prefer subtlety. Their blog may sometimes seem like inane recollections of their day or childhood, but carefully embedded in each entry is subtext on a hefty topic, like for example racial harmony or urban planning. The MPs have better uses of their time than to sit in front of a computer and blog nostalgia. Clearly they are using our common childhood memories to connect. C'mon, we Singaporeans are a sappy bunch, suckers for Korean dramas and more family-oriented than most city-dwellers. Politics are about grassroots power - with their posts in various languages and different MPs focusing on separate niches like arts & design, minority issues, the p65 blog is much weightier than most people give them credit for.

Then to take some away - personal peeve
First, maybe I'm claustrophobic, but something personal: I hate frames, so I dislike the layout, even when the frame is inlaid. I prefer my customized frameless version.

If I put on my postmodernist glasses and analyze why I don't like the border of happy smiling MP faces, I guess I'm bothered by how much it reminds me of our GRC system. How I don't vote single politicians but by the gang.

The lack of dialog, the lack of engagement
"It's Where We Talk," claims the tagline in a handwritten font. I'm not sure who "we" refer to, but most readers of the p65 blogs are not satisfied with the level of political engagement. While Singapore bloggers were debating the GST hike in November 2006, the first posts from the MPs didn't come till much later. Even when that happened, some MPs were accused of not responding directly to comments readers left.

Lim Wee Kiat was singled out by a reader (named anonymously "Singaporean") as "the only P65 MP here on this blog who is willing to discuss govt policies." I'm sure there are many readers who are equally frustrated with the lack of dialog and engagement. So the return volley from the MPs is: why then, no one comes the webchats and real-life sessions (other than Young PAP members)?

Our impatient world
As David Harvey succinctly said of our post-modern times, we face "Time-space compression." (Space)Here I am blogging in the United States, but my readers come mainly from Singapore. (Time)Maybe the complaint about the lack of engagement is really a complaint about the lack of timely posts? Some of the most popular Singapore political bloggers are not just the best writers, they are the most frequent writers. Politicians, however, are probably not passionate bloggers. It's part of what they do, but my advice is for us readers to slow down and push for more engagement while not pushing for more frequency.

[End of portion about MPs]
The Asides
Thanks for reading so far, I really appreciate it, and would be happy if you could leave comments.

Intra-country income disparity is a global phenomenon, countries rich as the United States and (previously) poor like China are grappling with it. I believe in the power of open markets, even in thoughts and debate, so I'm happy I live in a generation where I can influence how we tackle this problem.

Coming from a background that's at best lower-middle income, I empathize that the lower income groups need help, but I'm concerned at how Singapore politics have pressured politicians into what appears to be more welfarism, at least in appearance. With our globalized, connected world, institutions need to be nimble and quick, and I think too many complex welfare policies will drag us down.

Major diversion - The carnival as a microcosm of society
The level of democracy is reflected in our Chingay carnival. I was once in a carnival in Aalst, a small town in Belgium, and almost every float that went past was political - whether local, Belgian, European, or world-wide. Yet they were mostly very funny, if offensive (not at a Borat level though). For a while I thought there was a huge Danish population, because everyone was waving Danish flags...then I realized it was about the cartoons.

Whereas our Chingay is sanctioned clean fun. Carnivals aside, where's our space for expression? Where's our freedom of speech? Is governmental control hurting us? Let me give a YouTube example - if I want to learn about Lee Kuan Yew and I search for videos, only 5 are returned, and the top hit is about a cabbie complaining about him. Oh, no, readers of my blog who come from gov.sg, please don't start uploading innocently proper LKY clips on YouTube - learn the lesson we have to... our participatory culture needs the government to realize we are moving beyond top-down, government implemented.

IR
Decades ago, the worlds (Beauty World, Gay World, Great World etc) were what would be regarded as Casino resorts today - they offered the glamor, the exoticism...yet they went away, or were taken away.

When we return these places of decadent fun (come on, we all know casinos bring with them sins like gambling, drinking, dirty money, prostitution etc), we can't just be reintroducing them to attract hedge fund managers (Wall Street Journal suggested that's why we're doing it). Bankers come and go, and increasingly maybe Singaporeans come and go, but everyone knows - the Singaporean will at least pause and think before they pack, but the banker is gone as fast as that Mercedes cab comes...

Malaysian Ad in Hokkien

0 comments

Petronas Chinese New Year 2006 clip in Hokkien (with Malay subs) on YouTube featuring some grannies bragging about their successful kids. Sounds very Singaporean too.

*spoilers*

The clip conveys a message similar to what PM Lee said about keeping family ties strong, but of course, the clip can't be aired on Singapore TV since it's in Hokkien. Moreover, the clip says family is more important than money - not quite the message Singapore's government would encourage.

New Amsterdam

0 comments

Originally published May 2006.

New Amsterdam

[Fiction - Draft]
Ian had taken a short trip to Benelux two years earlier, and all that survived from that time were flashes of memory constantly invaded by random noise. No, he had not smoked weed in Amsterdam. So the joke goes, he went for the canals. No hos either, why would he, when the only visits he pays Geylang are for killer beef hor fun. But truly he had been there for Van Gogh, Anne Frank and Rembrandt. Van Gogh struck a chord in looking for a new Japan in Europe. Ian felt like he himself was searching for utopia. His friends took the route of mushrooms and other Amster-gems, but he had objected to anything that modified his mind.

"But you have the death penalty too," he retorted to his American friend, though he conceded that hanging was more brutal than lethal injection. He was more unsettled by the fact that he only knew about Singapore's investments through reading the Journal and FT. An opposition madman had accused the incorruptible government of supporting Burma's druglords. He didn't care for the madman and would never vote for him or his party, even as the opponent was PDP. What he was concerned with was how Singapore tolerates Aung Sang Su Kyi being under house arrest. Then again, foreign journalists claim the same of Singapore's political dissidents.

Journalism in Singapore

2 comments

Losing Faith of the Printed Word
I just spent the past hour and a half watching a BBC documentary on Tehran, and what struck me was the spirit of journalism, both of the BBC journalist and the journalists in Tehran. If Prof. Mahbubani said journalists have a tough job in Singapore, I suppose he was not speaking in terms relative to Iran. The Iranian journalists seem to display tenacity and passion I don't sense from reading the Straits Times. But I'm making an unfair comparison because those Iranian journalists featured didn't work for the equivalent of the ST - they work for smaller outfits that nonetheless have impressive circulation.

In the documentary, Rageh Omaar said that despite being news-obsessed, Iranians were "losing faith of the printed word." They browse newspapers but don't buy them. They have the fourth largest blogging community in the world, and Iranians are increasingly turning to Satellite TV and the Internet.

Foreigners tend to have an overly pessimistic impression of Iran - that it is a repressive regime when in fact there are many elements of democracy. The documentary makes me feel Singapore doesn't stand very far from where Iran is in terms of media freedom. We all have to paraphrase issues in euphemistic ways, and that is if we're allowed to talk openly about them. Bloggers are ok, so long as they do not attract too much attention. The "red lines" or "OB markers" are too broad to be useful - we are allowed to say what we want as long as we know how to dance around land mines.

An Iranian film had to be censored extensively before it could be screened locally, but went on to win at International Film Festivals - sounds familiar to Singapore? Journalists, documentary makers, filmmakers, visual artists have a central part in our world, because they communicate to us and remind us what we should be doing to progress our world.

Perhaps the reason why Holland Village Voice started out as a novel modeled after Kundera's is because I deeply feel and fear that media freedom in Singapore is an illusion. I felt compelled to speak in riddles, as Kundera did.

The old (circa May 2006 elections) post below was my attempt at writing about a character who censors the Singapore media in his own way.

The Sound of Silence

[Fiction]
The living room sounded silent as Tina turned her key, so she was surprised to see her Pa sitting in front of the TV (he had muted the news because the Progress Democratic Party was on). Her Pa had declared a cold war on her ever since the campaigning started. She sighed, but felt amused her Pa was exercising his censorship over the PDP. A refreshing change from work, perhaps.

Pa had sustained an unforgettable memory of loss. His mother tongue (Hokkien), and his university were both systematically eliminated. He was a radical Chinese educated. Today he speaks Singlish proudly, as if never wanting to let go of the vestige of his identity.

"There is no Singaporean language," sends Tina through her MSN window. She has always been irked by her boyfriend's accent and consistently incorrect grammar, but she was exhausted from work, and in no mood to fight.

She wished she was back in the Village, shopping for trail mix or thumbing a discounted Murakami she was musing whether to buy or finish reading. Snapping out of the irrational wish, she turned on the TV in her own room so she can watch the PDP broadcast sans censorship. Somehow, her finger yearned for the mute button.